Sonoma County’s Best Restaurant Openings 2015

Valette Interior, Healdsburg, CA
Valette Interior, Healdsburg, CA

There’s always a great new restaurant opening somewhere in Sonoma County, and this year was no exception. 2015’s  lineup includes Michelin-worthy restaurants, fast-casual pizzerias, a vegetarian drive-thru, barbecue spots galore and even a neo-Jewish/Korean spot. All of these 2015 restaurant openings, however, share one thing in common: Awesomeness.

Here are our favorites of the year.

Amy’s Drive Thru, $

Amy's Burger prepared for the forthcoming Amy's Drive Thru from Amy's Kitchen
Amy’s Burger at Amy’s Drive Thru

The “healthy” fast food alternative created by Andy and Rachel Berliner of Amy’s Kitchen is focused on an all-vegetarian (and vegan/gluten-free friendly) menu that includes double stack veggie burgers, chili cheese fries, milkshakes, burritos, pizza and salads that are good for the planet and a whole lot better for you than traditional fast food.  The most popular item, not surprisingly, is the flagship Amy Burger ($4.29 with cheese), with freshly made buns, onions, lettuce, cheddar cheese, pickles, meatless patties and Fred Jr.’s secret sauce. (Insider info: Fred Jr. and Fred Sr. are the R+D team for Amy’s Kitchen that helped to develop the Amy’s Drive Thru menu.) “It’s fun to look at people’s faces. They’re so happy,” said Rachel Berliner. “This is food that even though it’s meatless, you don’t miss the meat,” she said. The (literally) million dollar question: Where and when will they expand? Judging by the still-lengthy lines at the drive-thru fans are coming back for more, and more, and more. More restaurants are in the works, but no word on exactly when. 58 Golf Course Dr. West, Rohnert Park. Open daily 10a.m. to 10p.m.

Valette, $$$

Ahi Tuna with macadamia snow at Valette in Healdsburg, CA
Ahi Tuna with macadamia snow at Valette in Healdsburg, CA

There’s a reason why people spend hundreds of dollars for a meal — to delight every sense, one at a time. Showcasing the best local products, well-studied technique and creative execution from pan to plate, Valette delivers on that promise. A gathering spot for the who’s who of Healdsburg, this upscale-yet-approachable restaurant is the namesake of Chef Dustin Valette, a longtime Charlie Palmer/Dry Creek Kitchen toque. Dishes are elaborate and carefully thought out to include a mix of textures, flavors, colors and culinary intrigue, so prepared for plenty of surprises. The best bet is to immerse yourself in the chef’s “Trust Me” tasting menu — a guided tour through four (or more) dishes on the menu. At $15 per course, you’ll get the most bang for your buck.  344 Center St., Healdsburg, (707) 473-0946, valettehealdsburg.com. Dinner service daily from 5:30p.m., lunch Friday and Saturday from 11:30a.m. to 2p.m.

Santa Rosa Seafood/Raw Bar, $$-$$$

Fish and Chips at Santa Rosa Seafood Raw Bar and Grill Photo: heather Irwin
Fish and Chips at Santa Rosa Seafood Raw Bar and Grill Photo: heather Irwin

For seafood in Sonoma County, it’s hard to beat this boat-to-table restaurant. An expansion of Santa Rosa Seafood’s retail shop, this casual cafe serves up destination-worthy fish tacos, fish and chips, and tuna ceviche along with more upscale classic seafood dishes like seafood cioppino, petrel sole piccata, grilled swordfish and North Beach style linguine with clams. This is the kind of fresh seafood you wish you could find at the Coast, but rarely do. Prepare to be hooked at first bite. 946 Santa Rosa Ave., Santa Rosa, (707) 579-2085. Open for lunch and dinner Wednesday through Sunday, santarosaseafood.com.

Bird and The Bottle, $$-$$$

Bird and The Bottle, a new Stark Reality Restaurant in Santa Rosa, CA
Bird and The Bottle, a new Stark Reality Restaurant in Santa Rosa, CA

Popular Sonoma County restaurateurs Mark and Terri Stark’s newest venture, Bird and The Bottle, is a marriage of East and West brought together by fire and schmaltz. Here, dishes like smoked black cod schmear and chicken skin cracklings fried in chicken fat (schmaltz) with Nashville hot sauce ($4) commingle with congee-style cheese grits, mac and cheese or buttermilk fried chicken. It’s a menu that not everyone gets, but the strange mash-up somehow works, with bold flavors, dishes that take a few risks, yet with the rib-sticking comfort qualities that the Starks’ restaurants have in spades. A great cocktail lineup and $1.5 million interior make it a favorite meet-up spot. 1055 Fourth St., Santa Rosa, (707) 568-4000. Open Sunday-Thursday, 11:30a.m. to 9:30p.m.; Friday and Saturday 11:30a.m. to 10p.m.

Hazel, $$-$$$

Short Ribs with Polenta at Hazel Restaurant in Occidental. Photo Heather Irwin.
Short Ribs with Polenta at Hazel Restaurant in Occidental. Photo Heather Irwin.

Two blisteringly hot wood-fired ovens are the muscle of Jim and Michele Wimborough’s Occidental restaurant, Hazel. Left by the previous owners of long-time French restaurant, Bistro des Copains, the ovens are being pressed into service for everything from house made sourdough loaves to whole braised branzino, perfectly-cooked pizzas, and every so often, pastry chef Michele’s chocolate chip cookies. Already being hailed as a new “West County classic”, the couple have quickly endeared themselves to the community with a mix of Mediterranean and California cuisines. Great weekend brunches as well. Open Tuesday through Sunday from 5p.m. to 10p.m.; brunch 10a.m. to 2p.m. Saturday and Sunday. 3782 Bohemian Hwy, Occidental, (707) 874-6003, restauranthazel.com.

Bistro 100, $$-$$$

hi1115_bistro100_mushroomtoastLocal, comfort classics with a French twist are the signature of this cozy Petaluma bistro. Here, everyone knows everyone or, if they don’t, the bistro tables lend themselves to casual conversation and knowing nods of approval as a lusty plate of short ribs arrives. Most of the food (and wine) is sourced from within 20 miles or less, giving diners a true taste of the bounty of the county. Best bets include mushroom and truffled bruschetta cream canapés and Sonoma County terrine, along with cabernet-braised short ribs. 140 2nd. Suite 100, Petaluma, (707) 981-8228. Open Tuesday through Sunday, 11:30 a.m. to 3:30 p.m. for lunch; happy hour 3:30 to 6:30 p.m.; dinner from 5 p.m, bistro100petaluma.com.

Persona Pizza, $

Persona Pizza will open in downtown Santa Rosa in March 2015
Persona Pizza will open in downtown Santa Rosa in March 2015

This bespoke fast-casual pizzeria features a small wood-fired oven that cooks your pizza at 800 degrees in about 90 seconds. Created by World Pizza Champion Glenn Cybulski, the dough is hand-stretched to order, and uses “00” Caputo flour (what the pros use). Serious bases of marinara, pesto, “bianca”(olive oil and garlic), and Margherita can be topped with pepperoni, Sopressata, meatball, anchovies, prosciutto, bacon, seasonal local veggies, pine nuts, caramelized onions, arugula, blue cheese and three types of mozzarella. Go for the winner of the World Pizza Competition in Napoli, the Chipotle Chicken, loaded with mozzarella, roasted chicken, chipotle sauce and fresh pico, its a bit gimmicky, but ends up being seriously addictive. OMG burrata salad (that’s fresh mozzarella with creamy ricotta in the middle), beets, arugula and vinaigrette. 701 Fourth St., Santa Rosa.

Dick Blomsters Korean Diner, $-$$

KFC (Korean Fried Crack) at Dick Blomster’s Korean Diner, a pop-up restaurant in Santa Rosa, at Don Taylor’s Omelette Express. Photo: Heather Irwin/The Press Democrat.
KFC (Korean Fried Crack) at Dick Blomster’s Korean Diner, a pop-up restaurant in Santa Rosa, at Don Taylor’s Omelette Express. Photo: Heather Irwin/The Press Democrat.

Follow your nose to this funky Korean pop-up where kimchee and KFC (Korean Fried Crack) are served up along with Kobe beef hot dogs (with pickled daikon and kimchee aioli, natch) and short rib mac and cheese. The sign goes up at 5p.m., outside Don Taylor’s Omelette Express after the pancakes and burgers are put away for the day. There are plenty of kid-friendly dishes that make this an experience for the whole family, along with fried PB&J with pop rocks for late-night diners. 112 Fourth St., Santa Rosa,(707) 869-8006. Open Wednesday through Sunday from 5p.m. to 10(ish)p.m., dickblomsters.com.

KinSmoke, Terry’s Southern BBQ, Sauced, Rossi’s 1906, Cochon Volant BBQ Smokehouse, Juicy Pig, $-$$

Burnt Ends at Sauced Barbecue in Petaluma, California
Burnt Ends at Sauced Barbecue in Petaluma, California

The new Sonoma aroma might just be wood-smoke and brisket. This year, barbecue restaurants popped up like gophers on a golf course. Turn around and another chef has spent a month in Austin, Texas learning the secrets of barbecue masters, and is now touting his secret sauce and philosophical approach to brisket. Call it an obsession.

With a “non-denominational” approach to regional barbecue, KINSmoke tops our list, featuring everything from St. Louis style pork ribs and Texas links to Alabama white sauce, Carolina mustard sauce and Texas brisket. With a serious approach to sides, they’re the all-around spot to get your ‘cue on, but be forewarned that when the brisket or ribs are gone for the day, they’re gone. 304 Center St., Healdsburg, 473-8440, kinsmoke.com, open daily for lunch and dinner.

Pig Ears at Rossi's 1906 in Sonoma, California. Photo Heather Irwin
Pig Ears at Rossi’s 1906 in Sonoma, California. Photo Heather Irwin

The return of Terry’s Southern Barbecue (5979 Commerce Blvd., Rohnert Park) is cause for celebration among its many fans for fall-off-the-bone ribs, hush puppies, catfish and Momma’s Boss Sauce, and sweet peach cobbler. Sauced (151 Petaluma Blvd. South, Petaluma,  saucedbbqandsprits.com) has the unicorn of West Coast barbecue, burnt ends, along with a monster-sized sweet potato with pulled pork, bacon, sour cream, chives and pretty much the kitchen sink of other goodies. Glen Ellen Star Chef Ari Weisswasser spent nearly a month in Austin learning the fine art of barbecue and has brought that back to Sonoma’s Rossi’s 1906 with a brand new menu. Working with owner Max Young, they’re calling it “Texas barbecue in a California context,” featuring authentic Texas BBQ with a Cali twist, like brisket and oysters. But its the brisket that Weisswasser has really put his heart and soul into. (401 Grove St., Sonoma, 343-0044, rossis1906.com). Juicy Pig: Recently-opened in Guerneville, with lots of promise from Chef Ruben Gomez. 16440 Fourth St., Guerneville, 604-7120. Newest to the lineup is Texas-style BBQ spot Cochon Volant, where Chef Rob Larman serves up ribs, brisket and pork shoulder sliced by the pound. 18350 Sonoma Highway, Sonoma, 509-5480, cochonvolantbbq.com.

Basilico Cucina Italiana, $$
Just-opened in Santa Rosa, this trattoria is the second from the owners of the critically-acclaimed Cucina Paradiso in Petaluma. Fresh pastas and real-deal Northern Italian entrees that go well beyond the usual spaghetti and meatballs fare.  4776 Sonoma Highway, Santa Rosa, (707) 539-0260.

Historic Twin Oaks Tavern Sold To HopMonk Owners

12/15/2013:D9: Sheila Groves-Tracey, the new owner of Twin Oaks Tavern in Penngrove, previously worked for several decades booking bands in nightclubs, festivals and theaters. PC: New owner of Twin Oaks Tavern, Sheila Groves-Tracey, pours drinks for her regular customers in Penngrove on Monday, November 25, 2013. (Conner Jay/The Press Democrat)

The nearly 100-year-old Twin Oaks Tavern in Penngrove has been purchased by HopMonk Tavern owner Dean Biersch. The co-founder of Gordon Biersch Brewing Company and restaurants and HopMonk Taverns.

Biersch takes over the roadhouse property from music booking agent Sheila Groves-Tracey and her business partners, who purchased Twin Oaks in 2013.

“In my mind the Twin Oaks is a ‘heritage’ hospitality site – one of the last roadhouse, tavern, honky-honks on the Old Redwood Highway,” said Biersch, reached by phone.

He plans to keep the name and ambiance that Twin Oaks Tavern (5745 Old Redwood Hwy, Penngrove) is known for while renovating and upgrading the space to include a new dance floor, expanded outdoor patio, and new kitchen. A licensing change will allow for families and children to enter the tavern to eat. Another major draw includes a lineup of 16 draft beers.

“It’s been running for 91-years continually, and that’s pretty cool. I’ve never considered (making it) another HopMonk,” he said. “Our biggest focus is to be a part of this great property, close to other craft breweries in Petaluma with a great beer, music and bar atmosphere,” Biersch added. He is co-owner of three HopMonk Taverns in Sebastopol, Sonoma and Novato.

Twin Oaks Tavern (Photo courtesy of Twin Oaks Tavern)
Twin Oaks Tavern (Photo courtesy of Twin Oaks Tavern)

Groves-Tracey will stay on to book the musical acts which include R&B, soul, classic rock, blues and bluegrass musicians. She previously booked musical talent for Petaluma’s Mystic Theater and in 2013 for Napa’s Bottlerock.

“She’s a booking legend north of the Golden Gate,” said Biersch. When Groves-Tracey and her partners purchased the tavern, they did some minor upgrades, but most notably added a music lineup that’s reinvigorated the historic property once a favorite with local ranchers. “We brought back the cowboy vibe,” she said.

Though Groves-Tracey declined to disclose the terms of the sale, she said that Biersch had approached her with interest in buying the bar. “The timing was right, the person was right, and Dean is a perfect fit to take Twin Oaks to the next level,” she said. “We brought it back to life, but now he can take it further. I’m really excited to see what he does,” she added.

The roadhouse is slated to close temporarily in late January 2016 for the initial remodel, re-opening in the spring, according to Biersch. Other upgrades will happen incrementally, he said.

“We may paint, but we’ll never change the neon or anything else about the classic exterior,” said Biersch, “We just want to make sure we’re stewarding this great property.”

 

Top 100 Wines: Winemakers You Should Know

anthony_beckmanAnthony Beckman
Balletto Vineyards & Winery
Russian River Valley
Beckman gave up a job as a news journalist in Washington, D.C., and Philadelphia for a job in San Francisco with a biotech website. That led to his exploration of Sonoma wine and yet another career change: winemaking. He earned an enology degree at UC Davis and worked his way up to become Balletto’s winemaker in early 2009. His talent put two wines on our Top 100: a lovely 2014 Rosé of Pinot Noir and a silky red Pinot Noir.

CTJ01027_KELLERESTATE2_678003Ana Keller
Keller Estate
Petaluma Gap
Trained in biochemistry, Ana Keller’s move to winemaking was a natural. A passion for plants didn’t hurt. Keller (seen in photo with her husband, Diego Tomda) works with her winemaking mate, Alex Holman, to produce brisk, focused Chardonnays and Pinot Noirs from Keller’s Petaluma Gap estate vineyard east of Petaluma, where wind and fog from the Pacific Ocean preserve the fresh acidity inherent in the grapes. The Keller 2012 La Cruz Vineyard Sonoma Coast Chardonnay, a Top 100 selection, reflects how fruit grown in a chilly climate can be transformed into elegant, food-friendly wines.

Steve Law
MacLaren Wine Co.
Sonoma
Born in Scotland, a resident of France for 10 years, and well-versed in French wine, Law brought a European sensibility to MacLaren, a small winery in Sonoma founded in 2007 by him and his wife, Heather.
Their focus is on cool-climate Syrah, although his 2014 Sauvignon Blanc from Dry Creek Valley knocked our socks off to earn a Top 100 spot.

Brian & Janice Schmidt
Estate 1856
Dry Creek Valley
“Who are these guys?” 2015 North Coast Wine Challenge judges asked when they learned they had awarded 97 points to the Estate 1856 Tzabaco Rancho Vineyard Duvall’s Prospect Cabernet Sauvignon from
Dry Creek Valley. The “guys” are the husband and wife team of Brian and Janice Schmidt; his family has farmed a portion of the former Tzabaco Rancho property in Dry Creek Valley for six generations, with Brian
helping his family transition to vineyards. Janice cut her winemaking teeth for 20 years at Jordan Vineyard & Winery, where she worked with its winemaker, Rob Davis, and legendary consultant Andre Tchelistcheff.

Steven Urberg Gloria Ferrer vineyardSteven Urberg
Gloria Ferrer Caves & Vineyards
Carneros
Behind every executive winemaker — Bob Iantosca in this case — is a hands-on, day-to-day winemaker who doesn’t always get the credit deserved. Urberg is that guy, taking over most of the winemaking decisions at this sparkling- and still-wine producer. After 20 years with Gloria Ferrer, Iantosca has taken on more marketing responsibilities, but not before becoming the most-awarded sparkling wine maker in the U.S. Urberg, a Detroit native with a chemistry background, has filled Iantosca’s shoes admirably, as evidenced by his two bubblies that cracked the Top 100.

Top 100 Wines: Meet & Greet Nick Goldschmidt

Nick Goldschmidt vineyardNo Wine Country is too far for Nick Goldschmidt. The winemaker’s home base is Healdsburg, and his Cabernet Sauvignons and Merlots from Alexander and Dry Creek valleys are typically terrific
(two made our Top 100).

Once the Sonoma Crush is over, Goldschmidt hops on an airplane for New Zealand, Chile, Argentina or some other far-flung country, as a
consulting winemaker for 26 wineries. It’s a brutal life of travel, winemaking and sales calls across two hemispheres, but his five kids are
mostly grown, and Goldschmidt seems to thrive under the pressure. He was once asked, “How do you get it all done?” “I don’t do any of it very well,” he replied with a laugh.

He lied.

A New Zealand native, Goldschmidt moved to Sonoma full time in 1989 and was hired as associate winemaker at Simi Winery under Zelma Long and Paul Hobbs a year later. He became Simi’s chief winemaker in 1991, and later rose to vice-president positions at Allied Domecq Wines USA and Beam Estates.

Convinced that Alexander and Dry Creek valleys are ideal for growing Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot, Goldschmidt’s own Goldschmidt Vineyards brand focuses on those varietals (there’s also a rogue Napa
Cab). Under his Forefathers label comes an Alexander Valley Cabernet Sauvignon and New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc. Other Goldschmidt brands include Trig Point (Sonoma Coast), Fidelity (Alexander Valley), Chelsea Goldschmidt (Alexander and Dry Creek valleys), Katherine
Goldschmidt (Alexander Valley), Boulder Bank (New Zealand) and Chacras (Argentina).

This doesn’t count the wineries for which he
consults. Whew.

Top 100 Wines: Meet & Greet Martha McClellan

Hamel winemaker Martha McClellan

Open for a little more than a year, Hamel Family Wines is one of Sonoma’s most stylish — and ambitious — wineries. Evidence of that ambition? Owners George and Pam Hamel brought in Martha McClellan, one of Napa Valley’s most accomplished winemakers, to work with their winemaker son, John B. Hamel II, and their estate-grown grapes.

McClellan and her husband, longtime Harlan Estate winemaker Bob Levy, have their own Napa Valley label, Levy & McClellan, a tiny-production, Cabernet Sauvignon-based wine that is being offered by a Napa Valley fine-wine shop for $600 a bottle. Her winemaking
skills are also behind the success of the Checkerboard Vineyard and Vineyard 7 & 8 Napa brands.

While living in Germany, McClellan graduated from Geisenheim University, the only American woman to complete a degree in enology and viticulture there. She worked six vintages (1995-2000) at Harlan Estate in Napa Valley, which led to similarly prestigious positions and consulting work throughout Napa Valley. At Hamel, she produces Sauvignon Blanc, rosé, Isthmus (a Bordeaux-style red blend) and our Top 100 pick, an estate Zinfandel.

They all show the finesse of an experienced winemaking hand. That Hamel looked to a Napa winemaker doesn’t mean its wines will automatically be outstanding, or better than anything else produced in Sonoma. It means that the winery found the right fit.

Top 100 Wines: Joe Benziger

Joe Benziger Imagery EstateCinsault , Lagrein, Mourvedre, Tannat, Teroldego … not your everyday grape varieties in Sonoma, but they’re a big part of Joe Benziger’s life.

As winemaker at Imagery Estate Winery, Benziger never met a wine grape he didn’t like. Sure, he produces more recognizable wines, too, such as Sauvignon Blanc, Pinot Gris, Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot, yet it’s the oddballs he embraces, from grapes he says are too good to get swallowed up in blends. They deserve to stand on their own.

Take Barbera. The workhorse grape in the Northern Italy region of Piedmont, it produces wines with high acidity and crunchy tannins. Imagery’s version is a bit softer and fruitier, with full body and deep, rich flavors, yet retains the expected refreshing acidity. Sodelicious is the 2012 Imagery Sonoma Valley Barbera that it won the Best of Show Red award at the 2015 North Coast Wine Challenge. Benziger’s 2012 Pine
Mountain-Cloverdale Peak Teroldego, another obscure (for here) variety, won a gold medal.

Case production of his wines is typically limited, and most are sold in the Glen Ellen tasting room. They come adorned with labels bearing contemporary art commissioned by Imagery art curator Bob Nugent.

In June 2015, Benziger’s family sold Imagery and the flagship Benziger Family Winery, also in Glen Ellen, to San Francisco-based The Wine Group. Joe is expected to continue making the Imagery wines, and keep the Sonoma diversity drive going.

Best Ever Toffee Oatmeal Cookie Recipe

Best Ever Toffee Cookies
Best Ever Toffee Cookies

Best EVER Toffee Oatmeal Cookie Recipe, Nancy Cole

These are super-decadent cookies that you can justify eating because they have old-fashioned oats. I let my dough sit overnight in the fridge, but beware, because the it’s addictive. Actually, I almost like the batter better than the cookies!

2 1/4 cups Old-fashioned oats
1 pkg. toffee bits
1 cup brown sugar
1 cup butter, softened
1 T. vanilla
3/4 cup sugar
1 2/3 cup flour
1 tsp. baking soda
1 tsp. baking powder
1/2 tsp. salt
2 large eggs

Preheat oven to 375 degrees. Mix oats and toffee bits and set aside. Sift flour, baking soda, baking powder, and salt together and set aside. Mix sugars until blended. Add butter and beat until creamy and smooth. Add eggs and vanilla. Add flour mixture and mix until just combined. Stir is oats and toffee bits and mix to combine.

Drop by Tablespoon on ungreased cookie sheet or silpat, 2″ apart. Bake 9-11 minutes or until golden brown*. After 3 to 4 minutes on the cookie sheet, transfer to wire rack and cool. Makes about 5 dozen cookies.

*Helpful hint: Take the cookies out of the oven when they are just starting to turn brown around the edges. The middle will look unbaked but by leaving them on the pans to set for 3-4 minutes they finish up and can easily be removed without falling apart. The longer you bake them, the crispier they will be. Store in air tight container to maintain chewiness of the cookies, although they won’t be around long enough!

Chocolate Crinkle Cookie Recipe

Chocolate Crinkle Cookies
Chocolate Crinkle Cookies

This recipe comes from a treasured community cookbook from small town near Humboldt Bay, with recipes spanning almost 100 years. Cook received a copy from her grandmother and cherishes the stories and memories of the community. We love these cookies, because they’re simple and old-fashioned, reminding us of the cookies we used to set out for Santa.

Chocolate Crinkles, Tianne Cook
Makes about 4 dozen

4 ounces bittersweet chocolate
½ cup vegetable oil
2 cups granulated sugar
4 unbeaten eggs
2 teaspoons vanilla
2 cups sifted flour
2 teaspoons baking powder
½ teaspoon salt
½ cup chopped walnuts
1 cup confectioner’s sugar

Line 2 baking sheets with parchment paper. Melt the Bittersweet Chocolate in a double boiler or mixing bowl over bowl of hot water. Remove from water and blend in oil and sugar. Add eggs one at a time and beat well after each addition and then beat in the vanilla.

Sift together flour, baking powder and salt. Stir into chocolate mixture; add nuts and mix. Chill soft dough for several hours or overnight.

Drop a slightly heaping tablespoon of dough into the confectioners’ sugar and roll to coat and form into a ball; repeat with remaining dough. Place the dough balls on a prepared baking sheet approximately 2 inches apart and refrigerate until chilled, about 30 minutes. Bake approximately 10-12 minutes at 350 degrees. Let cool on pan 10 minutes before transferring to cooling rack.

12 Amazing Cookie Recipes For the Holidays

Over seven years of the BiteClub Holiday Cookie Contest, this time of year finds me anchored to my stand mixer, whipping up dozens of recipes submitted by local bakers. I have tested hundreds of recipes, softened hundreds of pounds of butter, bought bag after bag of flour and wound up with a kitchen floor that’s sticky with powdered sugar until mid-May.

I thought maybe I had exhausted every possible version of chocolate chip, ginger, biscotti, thumbprint and caramel-coated cookies, but I was wrong.

This year, I tested about a dozen recipes and carefully considered the taste, the ease of construction and the story behind each one. A panel of friends, family and co-workers helped me select the winner.

The lemon snowflake cookies were standouts because of their unique refreshing quality and the heartfelt story behind Tonia Seidita’s favorite holiday cookie.

Here are some of this year, and previous years’ favorites.

>>See Even More Cookie Recipes HERE >>

1. Chocolate Crinkles

Chocolate Crinkle Cookies
Chocolate Crinkle Cookies

Kinda like a brownie, kinda like a cookie. Favorite of testers.

2. Jo’s Lemon Snowflake Cookies (Biteclub Holiday Cookie Contest Winner 2015)

hi1215_cookiecontest_lemon_horiz

A zesty, delicious cookie
Get Recipe (BiteClub Holiday Cookie Contest 2015)

3. World’s Best Sugar Cookie Recipe

hi1215_cookiecontest_sugar_large
So simple, so wonderful.
Get Recipe (BiteClub Holiday Cookie Contest 2015)

4. Yes We P’Can Tarts

Pecan Cookie Recipe
Shortbread and pecans. What could go wrong?
Get Recipe (BiteClub Holiday Cookie Contest 2011)

5. Salted Caramel Apple Cookies

hi1215_cookiecontest_caramelapple
First you taste the caramel. Then the apple. Oh man…
Get Recipe (BiteClub Holiday Cookie Contest 2011)

6. Nutella Chocolate Chip Cookies

Nutella Chocolate Chip Cookies
Nutella is my weakness
Get Recipe (BiteClub Holiday Cookie Contest 2011) 

7. Twilight Vampire Cookies

Twilight Vampire Cookies ©heather irwin
Sexy. Vampiry. Yummy.
Get Recipe (BiteClub Holiday Cookie Contest 2012)

8. Salted Chocolate Chip Cookies

Salted Chocolate Chip Cookies ©heather irwin
You’ll never look at chocolate chip cookies the same way again
Get Recipe (BiteClub Holiday Cookie Contest 2012)

9. Frank’s Red Hot Potato Chip Cookies

Frank's Red Hot Potato Chip Cookies ©heather irwin
Spicy good.
Get Recipe (BiteClub Holiday Cookie Contest 2012)

10. Bacon Fat Snickerdoodles

Bacon Fat Snickerdoodles


Yes, really.

Get Recipe (BiteClub Holiday Cookie Contest 2012)

11.Vegan Butternut Squash Spice Cookie

Butternut Squash Spice Cookie
Nobody puts Butternut in the corner.
Get Recipe (BiteClub Holiday Cookie Contest 2011)

12.Cranberry Orange Gluten Free Cookies

Cranberry Orange Gluten Free Cookies ©heather irwin
Gluten-free doesn’t have to be dull.
Get Recipe (BiteClub Holiday Cookie Contest 2011)

>>See Even More Cookie Recipes HERE >>

Jo’s Lemon Snowflake Cookie Recipe

Jo’s Lemon Snowflake Cookies

With so much chocolate and ginger this time of year, a nice tart lemon cookie is a refreshing change of pace. These are very lemony, but also very rich and buttery. They’re one of my personal favorites.

Submitted by Tonia Seidita

Recipe
1⁄2 cup butter, soft
1 cup granulated sugar
1⁄2 teaspoon vanilla
1⁄2 teaspoon lemon extract
1 egg
1 tablespoon lemon zest
2 tablespoons lemon juice
1⁄4 teaspoon salt
1⁄4 teaspoon baking soda
1⁄4 teaspoon baking powder
11/2 cup flour
1⁄2 cup powdered sugar

Process zest and granulated sugar in food processor for 30 seconds, until zest is ground fine. Cream together the zest and sugar with butter until light and fluffy. Mix in egg, vanilla, lemon extract and lemon juice, scrape sides and mix again. Stir together flour, salt, baking powder and soda just until mixed. Add flour mixture into wet mixture and mix together just until dough is formed, scrape sides and mix again. Refrigerate for 1⁄2 hour.

Meanwhile preheat oven to 350 degrees and line cookie sheets with parchment paper. Roll heaping teaspoons of dough into balls and cover in powdered sugar (be sure to cover thickly). Place balls 2 inches apart on cookie sheets and bake for 9-11 minutes or until tops have cracked and bottoms are just slightly golden. Rotate cookie sheets half way through.

Let cookies cool on sheets for 3 minutes and move to rack to cool thoroughly.

Tonia’s Story:
I love anything lemon flavored. These cookies have a great lemon flavor and their texture is delicate. I got a Blue ribbon for these at the Sonoma County Fair.

I am dedicating this recipe to my mother in-law, Jo, who always enjoyed all of the cookies I would bake for the Holidays. Last week I baked 5 types of cookies, including these, for Jo’s memorial.