From seasonal Dungeness crab to bay oysters to a variety of fish available throughout the year, local chefs have plenty of fresh material to work with when creating their seafood dishes.
Anello Family Crab & Seafood: This family-run crab and seafood shack is only open on weekends, making its famous Dungeness crab sandwiches a special treat. The Anello family brings fresh, quality seafood from their boats to their customers, with offerings of crab, grilled prawns in garlic butter, Lagunitas IPA-battered fish and chips and Grandma Mimi’s clam chowder. 1820 Westshore Road, Bodega Bay, 707-232-8002, anellofamilyseafood.com (Heather Irwin/Sonoma Magazine)
The Birds Cafe: Named for the movie that made Bodega Bay internationally famous, The Birds Cafe boasts sweeping bay views and a simple menu of classic seafood favorites. The fish tacos are loaded with fresh, crispy, beer-battered cod, the clam chowder has flavorful pieces of clam in every bite and the chunky lobster roll on a buttered brioche bun would warm an East Coaster’s heart. 1407 Highway 1 Bodega Bay, 707-875-2900, thebirdscafe.com (Jami N./Yelp)
Drakes Sonoma Coast: The Lodge at Bodega Bay has a full-service restaurant with a charming dining room featuring a large stone fireplace and a fireside lounge overlooking the Pacific. The only thing better than the cozy atmosphere is the seasonal sustainable seafood it serves all day. The Bodega Bay Dungeness crab Benedict is a breakfast must-have. For a romantic dinner, try the daily fish crudo or steamed Tomales Bay clams in a Sonoma chardonnay herb butter sauce. 103 Coast Highway 1, Bodega Bay, 707-377-5010, drakesbodegabay.com (Courtesy of Drakes Sonoma Coast)
Fisherman's Cove: When a seafood shack doubles as a bait shop, you know the restaurant means business. Fisherman’s Cove specializes in fresh oysters plucked right from Tomales Bay, and the grilled oysters with garlic butter and wasabi cocktail sauce are stars. The crab sandwich, with loads of fresh Dungeness crab on toasted ciabatta bread with a choice of cocktail sauce or dill aioli, also is highly recommended. 1850 Bay Flat Road, Bodega Bay, 707-377-4238, fishermanscovebodegabay.com (Courtesy of Fisherman's Cove)
Fishetarian Fish Market: This casual seafood shack on the Bodega Harbor boasts fresh-caught fish daily, healthy twists on traditional seafood favorites and picnic table seating right on the shore. You can’t go wrong with the classics here: Boston-style clam chowder (plus bread bowls from Franco-American Bakery and Mariposa Baking Co.) and beer-battered Panko-crusted rock cod fish and chips. The kids meals with sides of goldfish crackers and a fish-shaped cinnamon cookie makes adds to the market’s family-friendly character. 599 Highway 1, Bodega Bay, 707-875-9092, fishetarianfishmarket.com (Courtesy of Fishetarian)
Gourmet Au Bay: Add a wood-fired oven and a fully stocked wine bar to a waterfront seafood venue and you get the warm and inviting Gourmet Au Bay. Let the harissa shrimp on polenta and the fresh oven-roasted mussels in an herb wine sauce reel you in, then go for the generously topped smoked clam flatbread pizza with bacon, garlic and Parmesan. 412 Bay Flat Road, Bodega Bay, 707-875-9875, gourmetaubay.com (Heather Irwin/Sonoma Magazine)
Gourmet Au Bay in Bodega Bay is the Sonoma Coast's only waterside wine bar. (John Burgess/The Press Democrat)
Spud Point Crab Company: You can tell Spud Point takes crabbing seriously from the to-the-second timer on its website counting down to the start of crab season. Their stacked crab sandwich with housemade sauce consistently gets rave reviews, and the praiseworthy New England-style clam chowder rivals chowders found on the East Coast. You’ll also want to order the crab cakes with roasted red pepper sauce before they sell out (only available on weekends). 1910 Westshore Road, Bodega Bay, 707-875-9472, spudpointcrabco.com (Courtesy of Spud Point Crab Company)
Terrapin Creek Cafe & Restaurant: This quaint eatery has a warm and intimate setting, enhanced by a sophisticated menu of comforting seafood. Pan-roasted Hokkaido scallops are cooked to perfection, and the fresh crudo of Hamachi melts in your mouth, with bright notes of lemon and basil. Or try the Mediterranean fish stew, packed with big chunks of salmon, sole, calamari, clams and potatoes in a tomato and fennel broth. 1580 Eastshore Road, Bodega Bay, 707-875-2700, terrapincreekcafe.com (Beth Schlanker/The Press Democrat)
Gualala Seafood Shack: A small, no-frills shack by the ocean with a modest, straight-to-the-point menu of classic dishes is how to win over a seafood-lover’s heart. After a day of whale watching, steelhead trout fishing or hiking coastal bluffs, settle in for a meal of crisp local rockfish and chips with a side of housemade tartar sauce. For a bite of something fresh, zesty and colorful, go for the stuffed fish tacos with purple cabbage, pico de gallo and chipotle cream. 38820 S. Highway 1, Unit 104, Gualala, 707-884-9511, gualalaseafoodshack.com (Nate K./Yelp)
Coast Kitchen: The dreamy seaside Timber Cove Resort has a full-service restaurant with cozy seating options — you can take in the ocean view from the outdoor patio or pick a warm spot by the stone fireplace inside. Coast Kitchen offers seasonal fare, a long wine list and carefully presented dishes. Try the creamy smoked trout chowder, grilled salmon wings and corvina in a refreshing coconut citrus broth (pictured). 21780 Highway 1, Jenner, 707-847-3231, coastkitchensonoma.com (John Burgess/The Press Democrat)
River’s End Restaurant: Probably the most romantic seafood eatery on our list, River’s End is both a cozy inn and a fine-dining restaurant, graced by gorgeous sunset views over the ocean. While the menu changes with the seasons, it often includes oyster and wine pairings and the restaurant’s signature clam chowder. On this year’s menu, don’t miss the Kicking Ahi Salad, with seared rare big-eye ahi tuna, avocado and mandarin oranges tossed in an Asian-style vinaigrette. 11048 Highway 1, Jenner, 707-865-2484, ilovesunsets.com (Charlie Gesell/Sonoma Magazine)
Rocker Oysterfeller’s: Situated in the historic Valley Ford Hotel, Rocker Oysterfeller’s serves Southern comfort cuisine with ingredients sourced from nearby farms and fisheries. This translates to next-level Cajun-seasoned Dungeness crab cakes with a remoulade sauce, beer-battered rock cod fish tacos and barbecued Tomales Bay oysters (get the Louisiana hot oysters for a taste of Southern heat). 14415 Highway 1, Valley Ford, 707-876-1983, rockeroysterfellers.com (John Burgess/The Press Democrat)
Handline: Pairing sustainably sourced seafood with locally grown produce (much of it from the restaurant’s backyard), Handline excels in modern Californian cuisine that incorporates the Pacific. The fish tacos are draw here, made with beer-battered rockfish, fresh shaved cabbage, chipotle aioli, avocado and lime. Other fan favorites include the Monterey trout salad with a heavenly green goddess dressing and the La Sirena tostada with poached calamari, fresh veggies, citronette and pickled chile aioli. 935 Gravenstein Highway S., Sebastopol, 707-827-3744, handline.com (John Burgess/The Press Democrat)
Willi's Seafood & Raw Bar: The Starks’ premier seafood restaurant in Healdsburg has a tapas-style menu of eclectic twists on classics. Standouts — beyond the ever-popular warm Maine lobster roll — are the pan-roasted shrimp with chiles, charred octopus tacos with aji amarillo and pickled hearts of palm and the caramelized butterfish with miso vinaigrette and exotic mushrooms. The buffalo-style crispy fried oysters served on the half shell are a fabulous spicy, crunchy starter for the table. 403 Healdsburg Ave., Healdsburg, 707-433-9191, starkrestaurants.com (Beth Schlanker/The Press Democrat)
Casa del Mar: Pescado and camarones are here to switch up your regular Mexican food order. Santa Rosa’s Casa del Mar serves Mexican seafood dishes beyond the typical fish tacos (though those are great here, too). The Fiesta del Mar is a spicy concoction of marinated scallops, shrimp, octopus and red onions with cucumber and orange garnishes, all steeped in salsa negra. Other dishes to are the empanadas de camaron (empanadas filled with sauteed shrimp, cheese and vegetables) and mojarra frita (whole deep-fried tilapia served with rice and house salad). 3660 Stony Point Road, Santa Rosa, 707-541-6140, casadelmarsantarosa.com (Courtesy of Casa del Mar)
Santa Rosa Seafood: This seafood market on Santa Rosa Avenue has been selling fresh local and exotic fish to North Bay customers for more than 40 years. Fresh-caught crab is offered daily until it sells out, and those in the know wouldn’t leave without a pound of smoked salmon. You can find any other seafood you desire here, from bay scallops and calamari steaks to yellowtail and whole black cod. 946 Santa Rosa Ave., Santa Rosa, 707-579-2085, santarosaseafood.com (Heather Irwin/Sonoma Magazine)
Tony’s Galley Seafood & Bar: Chef Tony Ounpamornchai, the local chef behind other seafood-centric restaurants such as SEA Thai Bistro and SEA Thai Noodle Bar, set his sights on global seafood cuisine when he opened Tony’s Galley in Montgomery Village last year. You can see influences of the East Coast and East Asia in dishes like the Maine-style lobster roll with a dollop of tobiko and the fish and chips with a Japanese tartar sauce. Keep an eye on Tony’s favorites, such as the steamed mussels in a mild Panang curry broth and the spicy seafood pasta with prawns, Hokkaido scallops, calamari and fresh veggies. 722 Village Court, Santa Rosa, 707-303-7007, tonysgalley.com (Heather Irwin/Sonoma Magazine)
Simmer Claw Bar: Vietnamese-Cajun fusion is the kind of cuisine most of us didn’t know we needed. The crispy crave-worthy coconut shrimp are a winning treat every time, and the tender fried frog legs are a fun surprise. The true Simmer Claw Bar experience would be incomplete without a seafood boil: a pound of your choice of seafood (try the crawfish for a taste of Louisiana) with your choice of flavoring (Cajun, lemon pepper, garlic butter or the secret Simmer Sauce) and desired spice level. Order add-ons like potatoes, sausage and corn on the cob to fill out the meal. 595 Rohnert Park Expressway, Rohnert Park, 707-806-2080, simmerclawbar.com (Heather Irwin/Sonoma Magazine)
Anna’s Seafood: Skip the freezer aisle at the grocery store, and head to Anna’s Seafood next time you want fresh seafood. You can’t go wrong with the selections here, such as the rich sashimi-grade Pacific king salmon or meaty ahi tuna steaks. If you’re looking for ready-to-eat meals, try the assorted pokes, crab cioppino and smoked salmon. 901 Lakeville St., Petaluma, 707-664-5074, shopannasseafood.com (Courtesy of Anna's Seafood)
Quinua Restaurant: Peruvian cuisine is full of bright seafood dishes, and Quinua serves them with style and originality. It’s imperative to start with a ceviche, a traditional Peruvian dish, and the ceviche mixto is a delightful assortment of marinated seafood with citrus and spice. Fans of fried seafood will find comfort in the jalea de mariscos, accompanied by golden yucca and creamy rocoto pepper sauce and topped with salsa criolla. The paella Peruana is a glorious, colorful mess of seafood, rice and veggies seasoned with aji panca and amarillo. 500 Petaluma Blvd. S., Petaluma, 707-776-7789, quinuacocinaperuana.com (Courtesy of Quinua Restaurant)
The Shuckery: The Shuckery’s Lalicker sisters, known as the Oyster Girls, know their way around shellfish, much to the benefit of locals and visitors. Check out their daily selection of raw oysters or order the baked oysters (Rockefeller, BBQ, bingo or chef’s special). The mussels and clams are tender, delicate and savory, accompanied with grilled Della Fattoria bread to sop up the flavorful wine sauce. 100 Washington St., Petaluma, 707-981-7891, theshuckeryca.com (John Burgess/The Press Democrat)
La Salette Restaurant: Fresh seafood is at the heart of Portuguese cuisine, which La Salette does exceptionally well. You could get lost in the starters alone, such as the salt cod cakes, chouriço-crusted day boat scallops and sauteed Monterey squid. But the entrees that can’t be missed are the bacalhau no forno, a traditional Portuguese dish of salt cod in a baked casserole, and the caldeirada (or Portuguese fisherman’s stew) with sea bass, scallops, clams, mussels, shrimp, linguiça and fingerling potatoes. 452 First St. E., Suite H, Sonoma, 707-938-1927, lasaletterestaurant.com (John Burgess/The Press Democrat)
Reel & Brand: A casual surf-and-turf restaurant in a rustic venue, Reel & Brand is the kind of place you can bring a group of friends for a beer, good eats and live music. The tempura jumbo prawns served with a sweet and spicy dipping sauce is perfect for sharing. For a simple but satisfying meal, go for the large beer-battered fish and chips, served with housemade tartar sauce. For a more well-rounded meal, opt for the pan-seared salmon in a red wine reduction with sea salt mashed potato and cauliflower. 401 Grove St., Sonoma, 707-938-7204, reelandbrand.net (John Burgess/The Press Democrat)
Worth a Trip to Marin — The Marshall Store: Though it was named among The New York Times' “Top 50 Restaurants in America” last year, The Marshall Store remains an unpretentious oyster bar frequented by locals. Locals and visitors alike come for the fresh oysters, like the sought-after grilled Kilpatricks topped with garlic butter, Worcestershire sauce, bacon and parsley. But don’t miss the hearty, New England-style clam chowder or vibrant fish tacos with grilled mahi mahi. 19225 Highway 1, Marshall, 415-663-1339, themarshallstore.com (Christopher Chung/The Press Democrat)
Worth a Trip to Marin — Tony's Seafood Restaurant: Tony’s was established in 1948 by Croatian fisherman Anton ‘Tony’ Konatich. The seafood shack, now owned by Hog Island Oyster Co., is popular for its daily fish specials and locally caught shellfish, particularly the HIOC Clam Chowder, served in the style of a cioppino, with whole Manila clams and hunks of vegetables, potatoes and bacon in a cream-based broth. For something more on the crispy, carby side, go for the fried oyster po’boy with HIOC’s signature Hogwash slaw and housemade tartar sauce on a Route 1 hoagie roll. 18863 Highway 1, Marshall, 415-663-1107, hogislandoysters.com/restaurants/tonysseafood
In Sonoma County, with our proximity to the Pacific Ocean, we can enjoy fresh, straight-from-the-depths seafood at restaurants across the area. Bodega Bay is the hot spot for seafood, of course, with crab shacks and fish markets that also serve food. But don’t overlook places farther north, if you take a day trip to Jenner or Gualala, or spots inland in Santa Rosa, Sonoma and Petaluma.
Click through the above gallery for some of the best options, from the coast to inland.
